Monday, October 17, 2011

Hope You Love Groceries!

Kroger is basically building a replica of the 11th St store next to Arne's (on those great lots that could be something much more dynamic and beneficial to Houston).

Representatives from Super Neighborhood 22 (The West End) met with CM Gonzales and reps from Kroger to discuss the project. This is what we're getting:

The Kroger Plan
The new store will be about the same size and design as the store on Shepherd at 11th, which will remain open, as will the store on 20th at Yale. The store is expected to open about a year from now (Sept-Oct 2012). The amenities of the store will be similar to those at the 11th Street store. 
The property on which Kroger plans to build lies on the east side of Studemont north of Arne’s. The store will be at the south end of the property, facing the main customer parking lot to the north of the store. A fuel center will be placed at the north end of the property together with a small, secondary parking lot needed to fulfill code requirements.
Delivery docks will be located on the east and west faces of an extension on the south side of the store. The three main delivery dock doors will face east toward an industrial area. A small dock door will face west toward Studemont. 
Hicks will be cut through to meet Summer Street on the east side of the property. The City's intent is that this will become a through street, but there are some unspecified impediments. The portion of the block that is now Hicks will be improved to current City standards, and the whole block will be built like a City CIP project. Kroger will eventually dedicate that property to the City as street Right-of-Way in exchange for a smaller area of water/sewer ROW that the City will dedicate to Kroger. Access to the delivery docks will be from Hicks/Summer. An employee parking lot will occupy the portion of the lot south of Hicks/Summer next to Arne's; Kroger expects that Arne's will also use this lot at some point (possibly for its employees). 
The main entrance to the customer parking area will be just in front of (north of) the store. There will be a new median cut with a traffic signal at this point. The City will be working with Grocer's Supply to move their truck exit to this point. The existing median cut north of there will become a diagonal cut allowing southbound traffic access to the fuel center (and preventing trucks leaving Grocers Supply from cutting across/against traffic to use it to go north). There will be two distinct curb cuts for the fuel center entrance and exit.
There will be a pharmacy drive-through on the west side of the store, entered from the main drive entrance and exiting onto Hicks/Summer. 
Kroger will be doing a lot of landscaping on the median, along their side of the streets, and on their parking lot. I didn't note all the species, but the trees on the parking lot will be mostly Shumard oaks for shade with a few crepe myrtles for color. Texas native shrubs and other plantings were also mentioned. Kroger will be adopting the street and median, and will install an irrigation system to maintain the plants. The sidewalk along their property will be five feet wide (25% above minimum standard). Please find attached to this note three photographs of the Kroger plans displayed at the meeting.

Traffic Study
There was discussion of the effects of the proposed median changes on traffic flow, but there was no mention of formal traffic studies, either for the immediate area or surrounding areas.  
Drainage Plan
When asked about the project’s drainage plan, Kroger representatives told meeting attendees that because the amount of impervious surface is not expected to increase above historic levels that the site is "grand-fathered," meaning that no detention will be required. There was considerable discussion of the desirability of improving the drainage to meet current standards (as if this was a newly developed property). One of the Kroger employees agreed to discuss the feasibility of doing so with their engineering people.   
Planned Contribution to Olivewood Cemetery 
Kroger has also agreed to provide $40,000 for a new fence around Olivewood Cemetery (which lies just west of Grocers Supply).   
Economic Development Agreement(Pursuant to Chapter 380 of the Local Government Code) 
City Council will be considering a request from the administration to enter an Economic Development Agreement (a 380 Agreement) with Kroger pursuant to which Kroger will be reimbursed for improvements made to the City ROW. The reimbursements will be paid from city property and sales tax revenues produced by the Kroger store at this location, will be capped at $2.5M, and will be repaid over a period of 13 years. The 380 agreement is Agenda Item #16 on this week’s City Council agenda. The full text of the agreement is not included in the agenda backup materials posted on the City Secretary’s website. 

From my personal perspective, this project equals an as-if-you-thought-it-could-get-even-worse traffic nightmare on Studewood, a development that will be difficult to ever repurpose due to the gas station and over saturation of the market. Many food deserts still exist with in a few miles of this proposed location. Why not Lindale Park, Eastwood, Independence Heights?

However, a representative from Super Neighborhood 22 had positive things to say about this project, commenting that a grocery has been high on the wish list for the SN council for some time. So, good if the SN, which has a very well thought out plan for their neighborhood, approves. That tells me it's not as bad as I think it is. EDIT: RUMOR has it that SN 22 will actually be coming out against this project after further review. If & when they do, I'll update again.

Still, it leaves me sighing for yet another missed opportunity- and I certainly don't want to see my tax $ go to it. If it was in Independence Heights, a known food desert, I would say "Bring on the 380" but this just leaves me shaking my head. Again.

And for what is sure to be colorful discussion, follow the debate on this morning's Swamplot post.


  1. What a total shame. I'm Kroger-ed out. I wish the Heights could get another food supplier. Many thanks for Fiesta, but I was really hoping for at least an HEB like the Buffalo Market. If I had the gumption, I would open my own market. Something SMALLER (I hate this jumbo size crap), more on the size of the Fiesta at 14th, but with less selection of boxes of food. More emphasis on fresh foods, in-house prepared foods ready to cook at home, and a more natural grocery store, something like Trader Joe's. The only thing I like about Kroger is the self check.

  2. I am sick of Kroger as well. This is really disappointing. I would almost rather have a Wal Mart than another Kroger. I was also hoping for an HEB. I have recently been going to Kroger simply because it's close but I think I am going to start making the drive to HEB if they really are going to put a 3rd one up. Ridiculous.

  3. For the past few months I've shopped solely at the Fiesta on Studewood because I can't stand the parking or the busy-ness at 11th St Kroger. I love Fiesta's fresher produce and better meat prices, even if they don't always have some of the things I'm looking for.

  4. They need to shut down the Kroger on 20th! That is a NASTY store and I refuse to shop there. The 11th street store is very nice but too expensive. I'm hoping we get an HEB in the area soon.

  5. I like the Fiesta and the 20th Street Kroger because they are small. They may not be as shiny as the 11th St Kroger but over on 20th St it's pretty much the same food, the employees are nicer, and you don't have to walk 3 miles just collecting your groceries. If I want a giant food experience I'll trek over to Central Market.

    I would have been really happy to see the Trader Joe's going into the old Alabama Theater site over on Studewood. Much smaller (less traffic impact) and something different than the other options nearby.

    I predict lots of people at rush hour after work going into the Kroger, then sitting in the middle lane of Studewood blocking traffic trying to get into the I-10 turn lane to go back to Katy.

  6. @John I had to read your comment six times but what I think you mean is...

    I would have been really happy to see the Trader Joe's going into Studewood instead of going into the old Alabama Theater site on Kirby.

    Did I guess right?


  7. I would not get rid of the Kroger on 20th, alot of the senior citizens shop there because its easier. They live right across the street. Also for all those wanting an HEB its really not that far...maybe 10 min from the heights?

  8. So it was really early when I posted that, OK? You are exactly right LizBiz.

  9. I'm looking forward to the new Montrose HEB.

  10. this will likely cause a clusterfuck on studewood-- not looking forward to the traffic increase. blah

  11. that's so disappointing. the kroger on 11th, IMHO, stinks. it's too big and the produce is always bad. i think this studemont one is supposed to be a bit smaller, which is good, and maybe they can figure out how to have produce that doesn't go bad withing 48 hours of purchase and isnt buggy. gag. it's worth the 6 mile drive to go to HEB.

  12. The Heights area needs a new, clean grocery store. I don't know why you think the space could be used for something more beneficial. Certainly seems like a good decision to me. BTW, why post with such a slanted view??

  13. We are in the practice of creating strength and building self esteem, one individual at a time.
    Houston Weight Loss